CHALLENGE OF UNIVERSAL HEALTH COVERAGE IN INDIA

Last Updated on 19th December, 2024
7 minutes, 7 seconds

Description

Source: Hindu

Disclaimer: Copyright infringement not intended.

Context

Achieving Universal Health Coverage (UHC)  in India—a country marked by vast socio-economic, cultural and regional diversity—is challenging due to its complex healthcare systems and varying local health profiles.

Definition

Universal Health Coverage (UHC) aims to ensure that all individuals and communities receive the health services they need without financial hardship.

Key Components

Access to Care: Timely access to necessary health services.

Quality Services: Effective, safe, and reliable care.

Financial Protection: Avoidance of economic strain due to medical expenses.

Achieving UHC is a key goal under the 2030 Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs).

UHC in India

Constitutional Provisions

Directive Principles: Articles 39(e), 42 and 47 direct the state to ensure public health, nutrition and humane work conditions.

Local Bodies: Article 243G empowers panchayats and municipalities to enhance public health.

Policies and Programs

National Health Policy (1983): Emphasized “Health for All” and equitable healthcare.

Ayushman Bharat (PM-JAY): World’s largest publicly financed health insurance scheme covering over 500 million individuals.

National Rural Health Mission (NRHM): Strengthened rural healthcare with a focus on maternal and child health, immunization, and nutrition.

National Health Policy (2017): Reinforced UHC goals through primary and preventive healthcare.

Need for UHC in India

High Out-of-Pocket Expenditure: Over 40% of healthcare costs are borne directly by citizens pushing over 60 million into poverty annually.

COVID-19 Impact: Highlighted the necessity for robust healthcare systems.

Coordination Issues: Multiple schemes with limited integration lead to inefficiencies.

Preventive Health Focus: Early detection and management reduce chronic disease burden.

India's Health System Diversity

India exhibits various healthcare models with significant regional variations.

Some states combine public and private systems while others lean heavily on one type.

For instance Kerala has a strong public health system while states like Bihar depend more on private healthcare providers.

Government Healthcare Expenditure

Disparities Among States

Per capita government spending on health varies significantly as noted in the National Health Accounts (NHA) Estimates for India (2019-20):

Himachal Pradesh: ₹3,829

Kerala: ₹2,590

Tamil Nadu: ₹2,039

Uttar Pradesh: ₹951

Bihar: ₹701

Epidemiological Contrasts

Fertility rates and teenage pregnancies vary widely across states. The National Family Health Survey (NFHS-5, 2019-2021) highlights:

Kerala: Teenage pregnancy rate 2.4%; fertility rate 1.8

West Bengal: Teenage pregnancy rate 16%; fertility rate 1.6

These contrasts underscore the need for tailored UHC approaches for different states.

Challenges in Achieving UHC

High Out-of-Pocket Expenditure (OOPE)

A significant proportion of healthcare costs are borne by individuals. According to the NHA (2019-20):

West Bengal: OOPE 67%

Andhra Pradesh: OOPE 64%

Despite increased government spending OOPE remains high due to systemic inefficiencies and limited access to free public healthcare.

Design Challenges in Health Systems

Increased funding alone does not address systemic design flaws. For example: High C-section rates in public hospitals of West Bengal indicate a sufficient supply of public hospitals yet schemes like Swasthya Sathi channel resources to private hospitals unnecessarily.

This suggests a mismatch between healthcare supply and the intended objectives of public health schemes.

Regional Health Profiles

Non-communicable diseases (NCDs) present unique challenges across states. The Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR) data highlights:

West Bengal: High rates of genetically inherited insulin insufficiency (high diabetes prevalence) but relatively low hypertension rates.

Kerala and Tamil Nadu: Both high diabetes and hypertension prevalence.

Such variations necessitate region-specific health strategies and tailored public health messaging.

Gaps in Primary Healthcare

Primary healthcare infrastructure is inadequate in many states. According to the Rural Health Statistics (2020-21):

West Bengal faces a 58% shortfall in Primary Health Centres (PHCs) and Health and Wellness Centres (HWCs).

This limits access to early diagnosis, preventive care and management of chronic conditions like diabetes.

Lessons for UHC Implementation

Region-Specific Strategies

UHC must adapt to the unique health challenges of each state. For example:

Addressing insulin insufficiency in West Bengal requires a focus on diabetes care at PHCs.

Kerala’s dual burden of diabetes and hypertension calls for integrated NCD management programs.

Strengthening Primary Healthcare

Bridging infrastructure gaps is essential. Investments should prioritize:

Setting up new PHCs and HWCs.

Ensuring adequate staffing and equipment for these centers to provide preventive and curative services.

Reducing OOPE

Transition from OOPE-driven healthcare to government-financed systems.

Utilize existing public hospitals effectively instead of relying on private healthcare schemes.

Addressing Inequities

Financial and administrative support must target states with low healthcare spending to ensure equity.

Tailored policies can help bring parity in healthcare access across states.

Way Forward

Holistic Policy Approaches

Integrate public health initiatives with regional adaptations to address state-specific challenges.

Consider socio-cultural and historical contexts to design effective interventions.

Building Climate-Resilient Health Systems

Address the impact of climate change on disease patterns and healthcare infrastructure.

Strengthen surveillance and response systems for emerging health threats.

Leveraging Technology

Digital health tools like telemedicine and electronic health records can bridge gaps in rural and underserved areas.

Expand access to healthcare through mobile health units and online platforms.

Public Awareness and Community Engagement

Promote health literacy through campaigns targeting lifestyle-related diseases like diabetes and hypertension.

Empower local communities to participate in health system governance.

Sources:

Hindu

 

PRACTICE QUESTION

Q.What are the major challenges in achieving Universal Health Coverage (UHC) in India? Critically analyze how these challenges can be overcome. 250 Words.

Free access to e-paper and WhatsApp updates

Let's Get In Touch!