INDIA'S PUSH FOR BHARAT SMALL REACTORS

27th January, 2025

The recent Request for Proposal (RFP) by the Nuclear Power Corporation of India Ltd (NPCIL) for Bharat Small Reactors (BSRs) is a right step in India's journey toward small modular reactors. However, restrictive conditions for private sector participation have raised many concerns. India has made many advancements in nuclear technology but the sector still faces structural challenges requiring transformative reforms.

Current Regulatory System of India's Nuclear Energy Sector

Centralized Control

India's nuclear energy is governed by the Atomic Energy Act, 1962, granting exclusive control to the central government. The Atomic Energy Regulatory Board (AERB) ensures compliance with safety standards.

Liability and Insurance

The Civil Liability for Nuclear Damage Act 2010 caps operator liability at ₹1,500 crore supported by the India Nuclear Insurance Pool (INIP) for accident coverage.

International Compliance

India adheres to IAEA safeguards under the Indo-US Civil Nuclear Agreement while maintaining strategic autonomy by staying out of the Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT).

Why is Nuclear Energy Significant for India?

Diversification of Energy Mix

Nuclear energy provides reliable power and reduces dependence on coal, which supplies 55% of India’s energy. India has plans to increase nuclear capacity from 7.5 GW to 100 GW by 2047. Nuclear energy will diversify the energy portfolio and complement renewables in India.

Climate Change Mitigation

As a low-carbon energy source, nuclear energy supports India’s commitment to net-zero emissions by 2070. It is essential for replacing coal and stabilizing grids reliant on intermittent renewables. Nuclear is expected to contribute 22.48 GW by 2031-32, aiding India’s target of 500 GW non-fossil energy by 2030.

Economic Growth and Job Creation

The sector stimulates economic growth, with projects like the Kudankulam expansion creating jobs in construction, R&D, and manufacturing. The development of Bharat Small Modular Reactors (BSMRs) promises further innovation and employment opportunities.

Base-Load Energy for Renewables

Unlike solar and wind, nuclear energy offers consistent base-load power, stabilizing grids amid growing renewable energy penetration.

Strategic and Geopolitical Leverage

Nuclear energy strengthens India’s global energy diplomacy. Indigenous advancements like Prototype Fast Breeder Reactor at Kalpakkam show India's technological capabilities.

Challenges Hindering India’s Nuclear Growth

Limited Energy Contribution

Despite decades of effort, nuclear energy contributes only 1.6% to India’s energy mix. Progress toward the ambitious 25% target by 2050 remains slow.

Financial Constraints

High capital costs, lengthy gestation periods, and restrictions under the Atomic Energy Act, 1962 deter private and foreign investment.

Dependence on Imported Nuclear Fuel

Limited domestic uranium reserves and geopolitical risks impact fuel security. Strategic nuclear fuel reserves remain insufficient.

Public Opposition and Safety Concerns

Safety apprehensions, fueled by incidents like Fukushima, have led to protests and delays, such as at the Kudankulam plant. A robust waste management system is still absent.

Technological Delays

Outdated technology and bureaucratic inefficiencies delay critical projects like the Prototype Fast Breeder Reactor, expected since 2012 but yet to be fully operational.

High Costs and Foreign Dependency

The levelized cost of nuclear energy remains high compared to renewables. Dependence on foreign technology limits India’s strategic autonomy.

Workforce Shortages

A shortage of skilled professionals for reactor operations and R&D hinders scalability and safety compliance.

Strategies to Revamp India’s Nuclear Sector

Private Sector Participation

Amend the Atomic Energy Act, 1962, to enable private sector participation while maintaining strict regulatory oversight. A hybrid model combining public oversight with private innovation can fast-track projects.

Indigenous Technology Development

Focus on advancing indigenous technologies like Fast Breeder Reactors and Small Modular Reactors through public-private collaborations. Integrating MSMEs into the supply chain can boost scalability.

Strategic Nuclear Fuel Reserves

Secure long-term uranium supplies through agreements with Russia, Kazakhstan, and Canada while developing thorium-based fuel-cycle technologies.

Land Acquisition and Rehabilitation

Streamline land acquisition under the Right to Fair Compensation Act, 2013, ensuring transparency, fair compensation, and sustainable rehabilitation.

Transparent Regulatory Frameworks

Modernize regulatory frameworks to attract investment and ensure public trust. Strengthen the AERB's capacity for oversight and compliance.

Investment in R&D and Training

Expand intake capacities of institutions like BARC to address workforce shortages. Enhanced R&D funding can further fast-track technological innovation.

Public Awareness Campaigns

Increase public outreach to build trust in nuclear energy’s safety, addressing concerns about waste management and disaster resilience.

Conclusion

India’s nuclear sector stands at a crossroads. It has immense potential to transform its energy sector. Certain things that are crucial to unlock the sector’s capabilities are--addressing policy bottlenecks, fostering private participation and advancing indigenous technologies. Nuclear energy will play a major role in India’s journey toward a sustainable, energy-secure and climate-resilient future.